Citrix HDX 3D vs PCoIP

Donwloand des Vergleich Citirx HDX 3D VMware PCoIP als PDF:

Citrix HDX 3D vs PCoIP

 

Operating System                                                           PCoIP                      Citrix HDX 3D

Windows                            XP 32bit                                Yes                          Yes

Windows                            XP 64bit                                Only PCoIP supports the full gamut of operating systems used by workstation users,

                                                                                         Yes                                          No              including 64-bit Windows and Linux.

Windows                           Vista 32bit                               Yes                           No

Windows                           Vista 64bit                               Yes                           No

Windows                           Win7 32bit                               Yes                           No

Windows                           Win7 64bit                               Yes                           No

Linux                                 32 bit                                  Yes                           No

Linux                                 64 bit                                  Yes                           No

Applications and Graphics

Application              All applications and versions                                                                    Only PCoIP protocol ensures compatibility

independent                         supported                                                                                  with current and future versions of all

Yes                           No              applications

Graphics processor        No GPU driver or hardware                                                                     HDX 3D works only with a CUDA-enabled

independent                      dependencies                                                                               Nvidia GPU and drivers.   This may result in

Yes                           No              driver dependencies.

Display

Display resolution              Max DVI Resolution                  1920x1200                 1600x1200         1920x1200 is the maximum DVI resolution

Display resolution       30" Panel/Extended Resolution           2560x1600                 1600x1200         Using Thruput Dual-link DVI adapter

Display frame rate         Full DVI frame rate (60fps)                  Yes                           No              1920x1200 at 60fps

# Displays                 Multi-monitor capability                   up to 4                          1

Desktop Client

Hardware zero client       Zero client (no CPU, no OS)                                                                    E.g. Dell FX100, Teradici PCoIP Thin Client Portal , Devon IT PCoIP Thin Client TC10,,

                                                                   Yes                           No             

Zero client integrated into display              Yes                           No              E.g. Samsung 930ND, NC190, NC240

Software client                                                                    Yes                          Yes

Low power/low                                                                                                                          HDX 3D requires client CPU to handle the decompression

management client                                                                 Yes                           No             

Host Workstation

Dedicated host             Blade, rack or tower workstation                                                                 Both solutions require a dedicated workstation on the host.

workstation                                                                             Yes                          Yes              Zero host CPU load HDX 3D requires strong host CPU to handle

                                                                                                Yes                           No              additional compression load

Zero host GPU load                                                                  Yes                           No              HDX 3D requires CUDA-enabled Nvidia GPU

Workstation Platform Support

WAN optimized                                                                         Low bandwidth (1Mbps peak), high                                                               PCoIP WAN optimizations launched in May latency (up to 150ms) support 2009 with numerous active evaluations and deployments (even trans-Atlantic).

                                                                                                Yes                          Yes             

Build to lossless         Progressive build to lossless image

display                                 Yes                           No

ISV certification           Remote protocol certified on OEM                                                                PCoIP protocol certified with numerous ISVs hardware with workstation ISV                                                                  including Dassault Systemes (CATIA, software Solidworks), Autodesk (3DStudioMAX, Softimage), Siemens-UGS (NX, SolidEdge),Schlumberger (Petrel, GeoFrame), etc

                                           Yes                           No             

Full image quality        Perception-free image quality at full

support on LAN                           frame rate                               Yes                           No

Dynamically

adjustable image

quality                                                                                    Yes                           No

 

Weitere Infos zu VMware und PCoIP finden Sie hier.

 

Gegenüberstellung der Protokolle für die Desktop Virtualisierung

Die Protokolle RDP, Provision EOP, RGS, TCX, Teradici PCoIP und Pano Logic im Vergleich.